MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network is the premier social network for everyone interested or involved with the Filipino Martial Arts.

MyFMA.net features include photos, videos, events, forums, blogs, chat, and more.

News Feed

Brian Johns posted a video
Saturday
Patricia Romero promoted Guro Lawrence Motta's blog post Hammer time
Apr 16
Patricia Romero promoted Guro Lawrence Motta's group Motta Fighting Arts
Apr 13
James Windholtz posted photos
Apr 10
James Windholtz posted a video

MOKOMOKO 2017 STICK SPARRING ***

4 OF 4 JIMMY AND NAPOLEON. https://www.facebook.com/groups/320413651490604/ According to the judges after 4 exchanges it was 3-1 Napoleon. SO I had to play c...
Apr 10
Profile IconLefty Moon and Shannon Duval Meade joined MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network
Apr 10
Chan Quiambao and Anni are now friends
Apr 9
Marc Mendoza posted photos
Apr 6
andrew jaime pasa commented on Zach Jenkins's photo
Apr 6
andrew jaime pasa promoted Zach Jenkins's photo
Apr 6
James Windholtz posted photos
Apr 5
James Windholtz posted a video

MOKOMOKO 2017 KNIFE SPARRING ***

2 of 4 JIMMY AND DAVID. https://www.facebook.com/groups/320413651490604/ Skip to :40. This video has the best exchange of the event at 1:30. He won according...
Apr 5
This is an article I had printed in Black Belt Magazine as I wrote it before it was edited. I think my inclusion of "traditional" names for grips was a mistake because none of my Guro's ever used traditional names for knife grips, instead they usually used forehand grip and reverse grip. However I hope you enjoy the article and if you did read the Black Belt you will see that this article is quite different than what went to print.

I hope everyone enjoys this article.

What’s in a grip?

During a social gathering with some knife fighting practitioners there was a bit of a debate as to whether or not the reverse grip was the grip of the “real knife fighter”. This discussion was sparked by one of the instructor who stated that if a fighter held his knife in the “sabre grip instead of reverse grip usually meant he did not know how to use a knife”.

This is a statement I have heard many times in talking to martial artists but the grip that was the “real knife fighters grip” changed depending on who was giving the instruction. I am not knocking what was taught; it was a very good session taught by a very skilled martial artist. What I am trying to do is help remove some misconceptions about knife fighting and knife handling.

In FMA knife fighting grips are divided into 3 basic types; Dunggab grip, or reverse grip with the edge out, Sak Sak grip or forward grip, and Pikal grip, or edge in reverse grip (pikal supposedly means to rip). Each grip has its merits and its strengths. Of course there are many more variations but I am just working with what is most common.

In military knife fighting history they divided the grips into three basic grips. The forward hammer grip, the reverse hammer grip and the sabre grip (a looser more dexterous version of the forward hammer grip). Up until the 1970’s the reverse grip was derided by the military as the grip of the amateur. In fact early military knife experts such as Colonel Rex Applegate and William Fairburn in their famous books and military manuals stated many times that the reverse grip was the grip of the deranged and the inexperienced. 1950’s knife expert and US Marine hand to hand expert John Styers wrote a knife fighting dissertation for leatherneck magazine that was printed over a hand full of issues in Leatherneck Magazine. The Styers method is influenced by the method taught by Colonel A J Drexel Biddle and was based on using the Bowie knife in much the same manner as a sabre. Today Master at Arms James Albert Keating is a huge proponent of this type of knife use. (The interesting thing is that Styers used a short 18 inch baton in the reverse grip in this same series of articles.) These articles are collected in the classic book Cold Steel.

In the 1970’s with the American fascination with Kung Fu and eastern martial arts suddenly the reverse grip fighting styles began to creep into the military and the western mindset. Michael Echanis was a huge proponent of this type of fighting and was probably the source of the statement that the reverse grip fighting method being the hallmark of the real expert.
So is the reverse grip the hallmark of the superior knife fighter; absolutely not. It is however an excellent grip for certain knife applications. It is great to use if you want to keep your knife hidden until it is buried in your opponent. It is excellent for knives at extreme close range. It is my preferred grip against unarmed opponents. It is well suited for the mindset of defending against longer weapons such as sticks and machetes because it does not give a false impression of range. The reverse grip or Dunggab grip is great for slamming the blade through body armour and bone on downward strokes. Another important thing about the Dunggab grip is that you can put your thumb on the pommel to help keep your hand from slipping down the handle onto the blade on committed stabs.

The reverse grip has a some merit in knife fighting but it does have many weaknesses. You lose a full blade length of range with the knife in reverse grip. You complete throw away the ability to use snap cuts and other long range tactics such as the long range thrust and biomechanical attacks to the arms and legs at long range.

In a down and dirty close range fight the Sak Sak grip allows the dreadful tactic of stabbing the mid-section of an opponent up under the rib cage or the sewing machine attack where you hold the opponent and apply multiple stabs to his midsection. The Filipino knife systems often use footwork, range and timing to work around an opponent and use multiple slashes and stabs to weaken an opponent from long range or “largo” range. Reverse grip knife fighting completely nullifies this tactic but the clinch nullifies this tactic as well.

It is obvious there is no one perfect knife fighting grip or stance, however if you are looking to quickly kill an opponent, then reverse grip knife fighting with the proper tactics can be perfect for this. You can hide the blade and use it very effectively at close range. You can slash and stab with the knife. The reverse grip makes it possible to use the knife as a hook and a lever on an opponent. It lends itself to some interesting tactics, especially in clinching range. This is why the instructor’s method was perfectly suited for military use of the knife and reality base self-defence.

The other thing that is apparent is that neither grips show anything about the skill or knowledge of the knife fighter. What sets a tactical knife fighter apart from an amateur are many things. A skilled knife fighter rarely leads with the knife, except to bate an opponent to make a counter slash, but this is more of a duelling tactic, in real fighting a good knife fighter will usually protect his weapon by having it back and protecting it with his empty hand. Most importantly a real knife fighter will be adaptable and competent in using his knife in many different ways and will be able to move from different grips and stances depending on the situation. Just like there is not just one “real way” to stand when you fight empty hands, there is also no one way to hold a knife when you fight.

Just like empty hand fighting, there are many different ways to use a knife. Just about every culture in the world has a different take on knife fighting. Some have similar tactics, while some will contradict each other. It really does not matter what system you follow, only if it will work for you.
However regardless as to what grip an attacker holds his knife in there is very little likelihood that he or she is a trained knife fighter, but that makes no difference. A knife wielded by any aggressive attacker is very dangerous regardless of training. An untrained emotionally charged lunatic is probably more unpredictable then a trained knife fighter. Knives are lethal weapons and never should be underestimated in a self-defence situation. Regardless of training you will be at a huge disadvantage if you are empty handed and should regard every knife attacker as an expert.

Views: 972

Comment by Chris Sargent on November 13, 2012 at 7:39pm
Interesting article. After years of training the one thing that I have noticed about standard grip is it is more forgiving. You have more control and sensitivity on how you are cutting. Reverse grip always leads to a thrust. The nice thing about reverse grip is your ability to protect your bleeders....your wrists. Both grips have their uses but reverse grip is not easy for beginners to use because it is to easy to get the point caught up on things like clothing or if you thrust in and pull out the wrong way it is easy to disarm your own self. So what is the best grip? I say each grip commands a different attitude. The situation will dictate but by no means is one better than the other. A knife always cuts going in and coming out. I will say one thing putting your empty hand in front of your weapon hand is a fools bet. Unless your a master or something play it safe. Always make sure the attacker gets your point.
Comment by Marc Lawrence on November 13, 2012 at 10:37pm

Joel,

You are on the right track for you thoughts but you missed some. OK I will explain, some will start complaining about this or that and that's fine. There are five knife grips used in Filipino Martial Arts that have cataloged and listed in my book (The Basics Of Filipino Martial Art). These are: overlapping thumb grip, straight thumb grip, side thumb grip, ice pick and reverse blade grip. Each have own uses, and limitations.

Comment by Joel Huncar on November 14, 2012 at 7:58am

Thank you Marc and Chris...and I agree Marc this is not a complete list.  Another grip I did not use is the edge up grip one of my Guro's showed me when he was giving me a quick little lesson on opening a balisong.  I just kept to the basics with this article. 

 

Comment by Al S on November 15, 2012 at 7:50am

Guro Huncar,

Is it possible for you to indicate the issue of BB that your article was printed in? Thank you.

Comment by Joel Huncar on November 15, 2012 at 1:05pm

September 2012...but there were a few mistakes made when they edited it to fit their magazine.  I did not catch them on proofing, and also when I was trying to sell my credentials I mentioned my being named the Alberat Jiu Jitsu Association provincial instructor of the year in 2011 and they assumed that meant I teach Jiu Jitsu....I most definitely don't...so I was kind of worried about how this article looked when I saw it in print and also I was concerned that people might think I was trying to claim to teach arts that I have no certification in.  Writing and martial arts is delicate business and I hate to eat crow because of simple mistakes, but that is what happens some times.  I am going to be more careful in the future. 

Comment by Al S on November 19, 2012 at 7:40am

Guro Huncar,

I read your article in the BB September 2012 issue and noticed not only how much was edited out of your original content but how BB took the liberty of changing your words. However, the essence of the printed article and the original content are the same at least in my opinion.

The most likely reasoning for the editing was that BB wanted to pitch their books that they sale on their website by Michael D. Echanis. If they would have left that section out your entire written content might have fitted on the page.

Also, I think you will receive no negative feedback from valid sources regarding "About the author" in the printed article.

Comment

You need to be a member of MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network to add comments!

Join MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network

© 2017   Created by John R. Malmo.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service