MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network is the premier social network for everyone interested or involved with the Filipino Martial Arts.

MyFMA.net features include photos, videos, events, forums, blogs, chat, and more.

News Feed

Patrick Lee updated their profile
Jul 20
Kurt P. Leffler II updated their profile
Jul 19
Kurt P. Leffler II posted a status
Jul 19
Bill commented on the blog post 'The question no practitioner of FMA wants to hear'
"Punong Guro Edgar Sulite did a series of videos showing the use of field expedient weapons to…"
Jul 19
Cyrus Bongon updated their profile
Jul 19
Cyrus Bongon commented on John R. Malmo's page School Directory
"Nickelstick Balintawak Eskrima Baltimore MD Guro Cyrus Bongon Phone: 443 763 0420 Email:…"
Jul 19
Cyrus Bongon is now friends with Rob Mathers and Terryl Richardson
Jul 19
Bill replied to the discussion 'Reasons to Study Martial Arts'
"Dave, I've known Kash for over 15 yrs.. We met in texas in 2002 when I had to go to san…"
Jul 18
Zach Jenkins replied to the discussion 'Reasons to Study Martial Arts'
"Guro Dave, In my opinion BJJ, MMA, and perhaps TKD are among the most popular and successful.…"
Jul 17
Guro David Battaglia replied to the discussion 'Reasons to Study Martial Arts'
"Hi Bill, Thanks for the reply. It seems like TKD was set on fire in the 90's and is still…"
Jul 17
Bill Steven Lowery and jay douglass are now friends
Jul 17
Bill replied to the discussion 'Reasons to Study Martial Arts'
"Out here on gilligan's island aka guam, TKD and the MMA gyms are popping up faster than a pan…"
Jul 17

Okay, so now I have freekin' seen it all! I just came across a video of a FMA school promoting it's "hammer system" complete with Delrin practice hammers tucked in their waist bands. This instructor and his Uki were demonstrating basic "Hammer" defenses against a #2 delivery; a sweep block and a jamb. Are you serious? Do we really need to develop an entire system around an improvised weapon? Come on! Let's get serious. People are going to pay good money for your "Hammer System" and buy your ludicrous Delrin practice hammer (because, you know, nobody has one hanging around in the garage...oh wait, I have at least a dozen). If your students can't translate your stick work to whatever weapon comes to hand during an altercation - so much so that you have to make them a special, plastic practice hammer - then I think you kind of missed the point. Festishizing an improvised weapon just shows that you understand your system from the outside in, not the inside out. Can a hammer be used as a weapon? Certainly. I am a carpenter by trade and I guaranty I can cave in your skull with a framing hammer probably better than I can with a stick, mostly because I spent 25 years swinging one every single day. But I'll be damned if that justifies developing an entire teaching module around a household tool. If I threw a hammer to one of my students and said "block hard", I can assure you they would make the transition to this weapon without missing a beat. That's because I taught them to defend themselves with a weapon, not with the one and only weapon that has to be a certain length or diameter or has special grip coating or can only be acquired on the third Tuesday of April in an odd year from a blind princess. In FMA, we teach principals that can be applied no matter the environment or weapon. We don't do fetish, fad weapons; at least I don't.  That just seems completely pretentious and contrived.  What's next, Frying Pan Foo? Skill Saw Sinawali? Pipe Wrench Panantukan?

Been a long time since I posted anything.  Need to stretch my legs a little.

GLM

Views: 57

Comment

You need to be a member of MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network to add comments!

Join MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network

© 2017   Created by John R. Malmo.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service