MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network is the premier social network for everyone interested or involved with the Filipino Martial Arts.

MyFMA.net features include photos, videos, events, forums, blogs, chat, and more.

News Feed

Andy Donelson is now a member of MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network
Aug 7
Bill commented on the blog post 'BARK RIVER KNIVES MORO BORONG'
"I talked to Mike Stewart from Bark River a couple of months back and he stated  that there is…"
Aug 7
Black Swan Tactical posted a blog post
Aug 7
David Pratt is now a member of MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network
Jul 31
dennis hiser posted a status
"lahat ay matupad ang buhay sa pamamagitan ng sining ng taba."
Jul 19
dennis hiser updated their profile
Jul 17
dennis hiser posted a blog post

Back to the fight

I was out for awhile due to health concerns but am anticipating being back in the fight again soon.…See More
Jul 17
Rudy Gaytan commented on the group 'Sayas-Lastra Brotherhood'
"hello to all my kapatids out there.  much love to eddie for all he has given me that enriched…"
Jul 11
Rudy Gaytan replied to the discussion 'sayas lastra style'
"i was taught by eddie and got to train with his brother robert and sometimes  jorges son…"
Jul 11
Issu Delabyme posted a status
"Not complaining, but it has been so long to be accepted on this social media that I was not even aware I was."
Jul 8
Philip J Sipkov replied to the discussion 'sayas lastra style'
"Hello Garrett, I was taught by Jorge Lastra and  Marlan Fuentes. "
Jul 7
Gena Martinez updated their profile
Jul 7

The more time I spend in the FMA community, the more fascinated I become with the phenomenon of myth and its effect on the arts; their propagation and their popularity.  Since 1982, I have participated in one capacity or another in the FMA community; as a neophyte student, as a dedicated follower and as a leader and instructor.  Throughout this time, I have gained a deepening understanding of the effect of mythology, story-telling and creative history on the arts as a whole and on the individuals who participate in them.   Now, as I grow old in the art, I begin to question the myths I was taught.  Are they digestive aids or deeper lessons?

Story telling has two participants, the teller and the listener.  Both are willing participants in the phenomenon and both have a stake in the mythologies created.  The teller strives to preserve a legend, to legitimize his position and to inspire followers.  The listener seeks to gain something others cannot (or may not) gain, thereby setting himself apart and reinforcing/justifying his or her special and unique position in the world.  The listener has a need to fulfill a fantasy and play out , in a limited and controlled fashion, what Conrad calls the “Hero’s Journey”.   Legend is usually only a small part truth and mostly myth or lie.  The difference between a myth and a lie is that a myth reinforces archetypes and supports organized systems of belief that are at the core of a community while a lie is a falsehood told to support illicit aims or shameless self promotion.  There is a natural tendency in human communities to create stories and myths as a means of establishing complex tenets through simple parables and legendary examples.  One need not look far to see these myths in our FMA community.  We have all heard them and probably re-told them hundreds of times.  I myself have often participated in this very practice.  It is not surprising.  The Philippine culture has extraordinary roots in oral history and storytelling.  As most students know, there are thousands of islands in the archipelago and hundreds of languages; only a few of which have any pre-colonial history of written communication.  Legends, myths, stories, customs and social rules were passed from generation to generation through oral history.  If you have spent time among the Philippine people, you have probably heard many many stories.  Every culture has this.  But what makes it germane to us as students of the Philippine Martial Arts is the extent to which we buy into the myths and the meaning behind them.  As neophytes, we generally buy into these stories because they are simple and they place the mysterious knowledge we are about to learn before us in a simple, linear, logical pattern; easy to digest and fitting into our simple fantasies.  The true nature of what we are learning is contradictory, complex, layered in social, moral and spiritual ambiguity.  There is no simple path to the truth that fits our minds because our minds are incapable of understanding the whole of the universal truth.  That is why this is a lifetime study that yields at our elderly death only a modicum of wisdom.  That is also why we need stories and myths that help us make sense of what we are doing. 

But the truth appears to be nonsense.  Here is a good example.  We have all heard of the story that our forefathers in the art hid their knowledge and skill from the Spanish occupiers within the native dances.  Some posit that the ubiquitous Tinikling dance is indeed a method of teaching combat footwork or that the hand movements known as “Bulaklak” in indigenous dance are instead carefully choreographed “Cadena de Mano” movements.  I have even heard that the kerchief dance is a literal substitution of the kerchief for a sword.  All of these stories were told to me as gospel and as examples of how clever the Philippinos were; hiding their deadly knowledge right under the Spaniards’ noses.  It makes sense.   But, it is not true.  Were the native peoples forbidden to practice their deadly arts overtly?  Absolutely.  Did they then, as a whole, at one moment, make the collective decision to “hide” their art in the dance?  No.  That is absurd in an archipelago riddled with hundreds of tribes who warred as much among themselves as against the Spanish.  The truth is far more interesting and far less linear and much more difficult for westerners to understand – and therefore, nonsensical to our limited ability to understand.  The truth is that the movements within the dance and the movements of martial practice were always intertwined.   They are one in the same and simultaneously distinctly different. The distinction between expressive movement (dance) and combat movement (martial arts) was only determined by the circumstance and the outcome.  It is only in our neophyte limitation that we draw hard distinctions between the two and have a need to erect these constructs of mythology to support that limited understanding and a false sense of grandeur.   In indigenous tribes, there is no distinction between dance and martial movement except context.  So, imagine how absurd the Spanish must have looked to the Philippine people who continued to participate in their cultural activities “practicing” their art like breathing air; the Spanish too limited in their capacity to see the martial and the expressive coexisting.  This is far more powerful, far more empowering of the Philippine people than our simplistic “hiding the art in the dance” myth.  This same concept can be applied to much of what we do.  The way in which we swing a large blade owes as much or more to the mundane, daily chore of weed cutting as it does to the legendary battle of Magellan and Lapu-Lapu.  But cutting weeds does not sell an art; it has no uniform or fancy name (It is, however an outstanding way to learn how to cut with a large blade).  And erecting a myth or legend around these techniques actually may dishonor those who swung the tool in the dirt of toil.  So, you can see by these examples that these fancy myths we create around our art may very well dishonor our lineage rather than honor it – taking away the extraordinary from our predecessors and placing it in a repository of mythic adoration.

 What fascinates me more and more is that, instead of seeing these myths dispelled by instructors who are supposed to be digging deeper and deeper in to the mystery of our arts and stripping away the trappings of myth, I see the stories reinforced, re-affirmed and re-invented.  And, even more fascinating is that I now see new myths arise; some of which are complete fabrications with no basis in reality.  I watched one of these myths take shape before my very eyes from its first occurrence to its adoption into the curriculum.  It even contains a complete anachronism; supposedly drawing on ancient techniques designed to penetrate Spanish armor.  I watched a renowned Master of the art forget the actual technique, make up something on the spot and then build an elaborate story around it and immediately adopt it into the curriculum as he turned to me and said “This is how you will teach this technique from now on”.  It was not how I learned it from his teacher.   If you stick around as long as I have, you will see this happen a lot.  Lately, as some of my contemporaries strive to make their art relevant and “sexy”, I see them concoct these outrageous histories and invent new weapons for the gullible and willing neophyte to consume; and, right along with these inventions, go the requisite stories, myths and legends that legitimize or give credence to these “Masters”.   I find it somewhat ironic that even though I would rather eschew myth for truth, this new crop of Masters is simply doing what their ancestors did; telling stories.  The difference is that instead of creating myths that support moral and social tenets within a community, they offer fabrications and lies designed to further their legitimacy by supplying their gullible neophytes with the sugar coated simplicity they crave.

Views: 492

Comment by Rino Salonga on December 31, 2011 at 6:23pm

Thanks for the article.I definitely learned something from it and the inputs of various members.

Comment by Master Ron England on January 1, 2012 at 11:25pm

We should always remember that in order to understand the Filipino Martial Arts we should not only study the movements, but the cultural aspects as well. Many times I have passed on a story or a observation to my students or instructors that was told to me by my master GGM Pedoy. More than once after a seminar or cIass I have had some say to me that they appreciated learning the movements and the history of our art. As the seniors/elders of this art it is our responsibility to pass on all aspects of information, the hard part is to know what is fact or legend. I certinaly am not an expert, but I have been quoted in Wikapedia and have had a significant amount of information taken (ripped) right off my websites and posted on other people blogs, websites, etc. The point is, all information gained concerning the Filipino Martial Arts should be as they say "taken with a grain of salt". As we all know, oral and written history is subject to being flawed. Even the so called experts are many times proven inaccurate or simply wrong. Since none of us were there in ancient times, we are forced to learn from oral and written information, Just try to do your research before passing on information to the people that are listening to what you say or write. Many times I have heard someone say, that the techniqes that some other instructor is teaching will get someone injured or killed and my reply is usually, well it is martial arts and anything you teach can get someone injured or killed if the movement is done at the wrong time. In closing, think before you speak or teach something and think twice before you critize someone else. Let us work to build the art up, not tear it down. Long Live Eskrima.

Comment by Joel Huncar on January 2, 2012 at 12:27am

Well said Master England!

Comment by Guro Lawrence Motta on January 2, 2012 at 9:00pm

Master Ron,

Thank you for your insights and criticisms.  However, I feel I may not have been clear and there may be some misunderstanding.  As I stated, myths and legends are essential means of conveying important tenets and morals within a cultural group.  I love the ancient legends and the story telling capacity of the Philippino people.  I find it absolutely fascinating.  But, I have some concerns about new "legends" that are scarcely more than fabrications and are not rooted in deep historical contexts.  They are convenient and alluring tales designed to capture the attention of gullible students rather than reflections of deep cultural identity.  And by provoking coment in a public forum, I hope to spur both introspection and criticism.  I think that is healthy.  Certainly, the legends of Norse mythology with a sentient hammer named Mjolnir or Greek mythology with Medussa's stony gaze bear little or no resemblence to what we may call reality.  But, we respect them and continue teaching them as they show us not only the roots of ancient cultures, but also important lessons and morals.  Legends within the FMA community should enjoy the same respect.  That, I do not deny.  But if I see someone fabricate an obvious new "legend", I feel it important to call the hoax for what it is; a disgraceful attempt to play on the gullibility of ones students.  I agree whole heartedly with your call to build the art rather than tearing it down.  But build it on a sound foundation, not a convenient "legend" that builds the artist and not the art.  I would like to see us admonish those who would trade on the ancient myths for personal gain, not those who point out that fact.  Thank you again for your comments.

Comment by Joel Huncar on January 2, 2012 at 10:58pm

I am sure some of these stories were made to lure gullable students but many masters were pretty secretive about their origins, and I think some of these stories were made up to hide their backgrounds as well. 

Comment by Joel Huncar on January 2, 2012 at 11:00pm

You are right most of them do not have the deep cultural depth that stories like the old legends from Europe's pagan past but unfortunately a lot of those legends were lost during the spanish occupation.  Perhaps many of these newer myths get retold because that is a void that needs to be filled. 

Comment by Joel Huncar on January 2, 2012 at 11:04pm

The same thing happened here in Canada with indiginous stories of the native people.  Now many are lost and many that come from cultures across canada become the myths of other people of other cultures.  A Cree myth may become a myth to another people, much like the sundance is now practiced by Native people all over not just the people of the western prairies.  People just seem to need mythology and maybe that is why some of these stories that may seem silly seem to get passed on again and again. 

Comment

You need to be a member of MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network to add comments!

Join MyFMA.net - Filipino Martial Arts Network

© 2019   Created by John R. Malmo.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service